Advancing New Hampshire Public Education

Home » Education Funding » Scott Marion: “Dan Innis is Playing Fast and Loose With the Facts”

Scott Marion: “Dan Innis is Playing Fast and Loose With the Facts”

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Categories

Scott Marion, of Rye, is the executive director of the Center for Assessment, a nationally respected Dover nonprofit helping state develop education policy.  Here is his response to Sen. Dan Innis’ recent statement supporting an expanded private school voucher program:

In his August 28th op-ed, Dan Innis likes to appear like a scholarly professor in his defense of school choice, but his selective use of “research” is anything but scholarly. First, Mr. Innis erroneously cites a 40-60 percent remedial education rate. As a national expert in educational assessment and accountability working in more than 35 states, I can tell you firsthand that those figures are wildly inflated. Mr. Innis should look closer to home where our NH community and technical colleges have done a terrific job in reducing remedial education challenges. In fact, a 2016 National Student Clearinghouse Research Center study, noted that New Hampshire four-year public colleges have the second highest college completion rates in the nation: 90.2 percent of full time students who started at one of New Hampshire’s four-year public colleges completed their studies within six years—the standard metric. That sounds pretty good to me!

Mr. Innis claims that U.S. scores on international tests have fallen. That’s not true. Yes, our relative rankings are not where we would like them to be, but these international rankings are not as simple as U.S. News makes them out to be. Further, when Massachusetts participated in Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA), it ranked almost as high as Shanghai. Given that NH performs at the top of our national assessments like MA, we can bet that NH would be almost as high in these international comparisons. Again, where’s the problem?

Mr. Innis’ most egregious errors, however, are when he tries to make the case for spending limited government money on school choice. He grasped at straws to find “research” to support some of his previous points, but when he comes to school choice, he equates schools with shopping for groceries and buying cars. Last I checked, it was a bit more complex to educate a diverse group of children than trying to find the best deal on eggs. In case that’s not bad enough, he tries to generalize from what is likely a 40+ year anecdote about his spouse’s attendance at the private Putney School.

If Senator Innis feels like students leaving our high schools are not well-prepared, he could have done much more during his time in Concord instead of latching onto some half-baked ideas about how to improve schools. For example, instead of trying to take money from public schools, Mr. Innis could have made an effort to increase NH’s shamefully low adequacy funding from approximately $3500/student to a level that doesn’t make a mockery of the term “adequacy.” Additionally, he could have proposed legislation to raise graduation standards so that all students have the coursework to succeed in college which is not the requirement today. He could have taken an even more effective step by drafting legislation to support high-quality pre-kindergarten for anyone who wants it. In this case there is a plethora of peer-reviewed research supporting the long-term benefits of such programs.  Did Mr. Innis take any of these productive steps? Of course not! That’s why I’m supporting Dr. Tom Sherman for State Senator—someone who supports our public schools!


2 Comments

  1. Michael Cahill says:

    What has Senator Innis done regarding School Building Aid? Hampton’s Middle School will not receive 30% of the project cost from the state. Property taxpayers are on the hook for the full amount. The same is true of the Stratham Cooperative Middle School and the Lincoln – Ackerman Elementary School in Hampton Falls. Where does the “education” Senator stand on ending the moratorium on School Building Aid?

  2. Public School is the best “cultures coming together to understand each other” effort.It takes understanding and not just knowing. Public school has helped me ‘understand’ even tho’ I was sent to Catholic school for five years out of 12 in public school.
    Catholic and other private schools emphasize what they “stand for”— not for learning about as many things as possible and being called on to ‘testing’ them out.

    Sincerely
    Mary Ellen Boudman
    now Retired Art Teacher
    from Newfound Regional High

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s