Advancing New Hampshire Public Education

Home » Vouchers (Page 10)

Category Archives: Vouchers

Categories

Sen. Stiles wrong to oppose voucher repeal (Dave Potter letter to the Portsmouth Herald)

From Dave Potter to the Portsmouth Herald

When I moved to North Hampton, folks described Sen. Nancy Stiles as consistent, reasonable, practical. What happened?

I know that today’s Republican party no longer has room for such people, but I think that’s what New Hampshire voters want. I urge Sen. Stiles to remember this and maintain the outlook that got her re-elected.

Why is Sen. Stiles opposing repeal of the education tax credit? She voted against the original bill because it was a bad idea. And now we find that a group called the Alliance for the Separation of School and State is using the program for its own political purposes — they say they want to shut down the public school system. Sen. Stiles was right the first time, and that has become even clearer as the program has unfolded.

We are not doing justice to our taxpayers, our businesses or our students in lending public support to a politicized form of religious education. It’s a bad use of public money, and the students will not be prepared for college or the New Hampshire work force. Future business growth, jobs and salaries will be tied to high-tech capabilities and creative minds, not an environment that denies science and modern thinking.

Nineteenth-century beliefs will not serve New Hampshire well, Sen. Stiles. Please remember why you voted against this bad idea in the first place and realize that, now that we know more about it, it’s even worse than we thought.

Dave Potter

North Hampton

Sen. Stiles wrong to oppose voucher repeal

Cathy Merwin and Greg Hill debate vouchers in the Laconia Daily Sun. Merwin wins!

Here’s an interesting exchange in the Laconia Daily Sun.  First, on March 5th, Cathy Merwin states the case against vouchers clearly and accurately.  Then, down below, you’ll see a March 6th response (how did he get it in so fast?) from former representative Greg Hill who, as always, is hostile and inaccurate.  I’ve inserted corrections to identify Mr. Hills major errors:

To the editor,

The Meredith candidates for school board have each attended numerous school board meetings and both seem aware of the issues facing the Inter-Lakes school district.

But Chris Mega and Mark Billings take different positions on the school voucher plan passed by the previous legislature and that difference is critical reflection of their outlook on public education.

(more…)

Vouchers: the news just gets worse and worse (letter from Joan Jacobs to the Portsmouth Herald)

use taxpayer dollars to replace public education with Christian education,” says Joan Jacobs.  Concisely put, Joan.

The more I learn about New Hampshire’s school voucher program, the more I realize it is a solution in search of a problem.

Bill Duncan’s opinion piece gives the public more evidence of how ill-advised this program is.

The advocates and the organization poised to administer the program are driven by a dangerous agenda. They aim to use taxpayer dollars to replace public education with Christian education.

The program enacted in the last legislature has no accountability mechanisms to make certain participating children get a quality education.

Vouchers are sold as a solution to help poor kids get a better education — but better and more accountable alternatives such as charter schools are available.

Since the voucher program isn’t going to do our state any good, the N.H. Legislature needs to repeal the law as soon as possible.

I urge state Sen. Nancy Stiles to revisit her original position on the issue and also to take a hard look at the accumulating evidence against vouchers and to vote for its repeal when HB370 comes before the Senate.

Joan Jacobs

Portsmouth

via Voucher program takes cash from public schools | SeacoastOnline.com.

A sampling of New Hampshire religious schools and their curricula

Here is a constantly expanding “inventory” of New Hampshire’s religious schools in a form that is easy to scan to see what they’re about.

The Bethlehem Christian School, an unaccredited K-12 school with 22 students and 2 teachers in Bethlehem, says that it “was founded in 1997 as a ministry of Bethlehem Christian Center, with the original intent of supporting the Christian churches of the North Country by providing a superior, Bible-based education for their children.”  Tuition is $2,500.  Bethlehem relies heavily on the ACE curriculum, saying, “our doctrinal statement very closely parallels the Statement of Faith of our accrediting, supervising, curriculum provider – Accelerated Christian Education Ministries.” Creationism is integral to the curriculum.

  • From a typical science:”True science will never contradict the Bible because God created both the universe and Scripture…If a scientific theory contradicts the Bible, then the theory is wrong and must be discarded.” 
  • Social studies: “The New Deal programs were based on the humanistic, socialistic philosophy that the ‘end justifies the means.’ To achieve FDR’s goal of halting the depression, Congress was willing to spend more than it had. Because of this overspending, the government raised taxes.”

Brentwood (Lighthouse) Christian Academy, an unaccredited preK-2 and 9-12 school with 8 students and 4 teachers in Brentwood, says that it “is a private entity and a ministry of Grace Ministries International.”  The say their goal is “to prepare students to be leaders in their world. The foundation of the educational program at BCA is the Word of God. We have found that students learn more effectively, understand their world more completely, and will change their world more powerfully when they view every aspect of their lives through the lens of God’s Word.”   Tuition is $4,500-$6,500.  BCA is  a member of the Association of Christian Schools International ( ACSI) and uses the ACE curriculum.  Biblical teaching is integrated into each course.

  • A sample science text says, “Biblical and scientific evidence seems to indicate that men and dinosaurs lived at the same time…. Fossilized tracks in the bed of the Paluxy River near Glen Rose, Texas, also give evidence that men and dinosaurs existed simultaneously. Fossilized human footprints and three-toed dinosaur tracks occur in the same rock stratum…. That dinosaurs existed with humans is an important discovery disproving the evolutionists’ theory that dinosaurs lived 70 million years before man. God created dinosaurs on the sixth day. He created man later the same day.”
  • The social science text says, for instance, “South Africa’s apartheid policy encouraged whites, Blacks, Coloureds, and Asians to develop their own independent ways of life. Separate living area and schools made it possible for each group to maintain and pass on their culture and heritage to their children….Blacks in South Africa earn more money and have higher standards of living than Blacks in other African countries.”

(more…)

Religious school curricula: a potent mix of religion and politics

The great majority of voucher and education tax credit schools around the country are religious schools.  For instance, in Florida’s six year-old education tax credit program that was, in many ways, a model for the New Hampshire program, over 73% of the schools, with 83% of the students, are  religious schools.  This ratio of religious schools is typical in voucher programs around the country.  While some are the traditional Catholic schools, the fundamentalist Christian schools are at the heart of the push  for voucher tax credits. In fact, voucher and religious school leaderships are so intertwined, you could almost say that the voucher movement is really about moving public dollars in Christian-based education.  But it’s not just Christian education, it’s the conservative Christian political views that have become familiar in the political arena. You see it in this recent speech by Tim LaHaye, high profile minister, writer and Christian school entrepreneur on the Christian Right:

…We are being destroyed in America by the public school systems of our country….and I’d like to see you join me in prayer that God would let us wrestle control of the American school system from the secularists, the anti-Christians and anti-Americans that want to bend the minds of our children. At our expense, they want to take the most priceless thing we have -the brains of our children – and let them educate them….That doesn’t make any sense to me. I’m hoping that this conservative movement will be long enough to get a majority who can vote what I consider a new bill of rights – a bill of parental rights where parents can decide where to send their children to school.

Pastor LaHaye is making the same voucher pitch Milton Friedman did, but stirring his theology into it.   The “parental rights” rap he uses is the rational for many bills, including the voucher tax credit, offered by libertarian conservatives in the New Hampshire Legislature.  Pastor LaHaye continues:

(more…)

Meet the Tri-City Christian Academy, epicenter of New Hampshire’s voucher tax credit program.

Most of New Hampshire’s Creationist Christian schools are unaccredited, but the Tri-City Christian Academy in Somersworth is the largest unaccredited private school in the State.  The Academy has  19 teachers and 344 students, mostly in the preK and elementary grades.  Accreditation is clearly a sensitive issue for the Academy.  Tri-City is currently accredited by Nicene Schools International which, they say, “was founded by our church and some friends from a church in Florida.”  Tri-City has been working on a more recognized accreditation for years and anticipated approval by the most important accreditor, the New England Association of Schools and Colleges, in 2011, but that has not been granted yet. The web site now features the prospect that the school is a candidate for accreditation sometime in the future.  Tuition is about $4,000 per year.

New Hampshire’s Christian schools were the main lobbyists supporting the voucher bill – and the Tri-City Christian Academy was central to that effort.  Tri-City principal Paul Edgar and 3 others from the Academy testified to the Senate Education Committee on the bill.  Mr. Edgar testified on behalf of the Granite State Christian Schools Association, who’s address is c/o Tri-City, saying that the education tax credit would relieve overcrowding in NH schools.  Mr. Edgar later sent another letter to Senate Education Committee saying that his school was struggling and that Christian school parents had to pay twice for their educations since they paid local taxes whether or not they went to the public schools.  Here is James Pinard, on the Academy’s professional development staff, speaking here for the Granite State Christian Schools Association.  Mr. Pinard has worked with the voucher sponsors and spoken at every public hearing on the bill.  A few weeks ago Mr. Pinard presented the bill’s sponsors with Distinguished Service Awards at the Association’s annual awards banquet.

And now that this voucher bill is passed, Tri-City has been in the forefront of marketing and defending the program.  Tri-City and New Hampshire’s only scholarship organization, a California group called the Network for Educational Opportunity, scheduled a scholarship information session at Tri-City’s open house.  The school’s web site looked like the state-wide headquarters for marketing the tax credit program and lobbying against repeal, urging parents to contact the Network for Educational Opportunity, apply for vouchers and persuade their legislators to oppose repeal.  Here is one example, a letter the Academy sent to all school parents urging them to apply for scholarships.  In response to the recent attention, Tri-City and NEO have wiped their web sites clean of all references to each other,  but their shared philosophy will surely continue to bind them.

(more…)

What are we buying with the voucher tax credit program? (Bill Duncan opinion piece in the Portsmouth Herald)

Here is my opinion piece from the Sunday Portsmouth Herald, updated here to include links to more detailed information I just posted Sunday night.  This piece urges readers to contact Sen. Stiles because she’s our senator and opposed vouchers last year.  But people should contact their own senators everywhere in the State.

Here is a short due diligence report for anyone considering supporting the voucher tax credit program enacted over the governor’s veto last year.

To date, only one “scholarship organization” has been approved to collect millions of dollars in potential business donations and then, after taking up to 10 percent off the top, to select the schools and children who will get the money. That’s a California group called the Alliance for the Separation of School and State. They opened an office in New Hampshire a couple of years ago, guided the sponsors in writing the legislation and lobbied for its passage.

They say their mission is “ending government involvement in education.” Here’s how they describe their beliefs:

“Our society has become a slave to the state by virtue of government-controlled schools. Children suffer, parents feel helpless, and scores of good educators feel trapped in a system that never should have existed in the first place. …

“Why shouldn’t the government be involved in education? The short answer: Government schooling stands in direct opposition to the liberty this country was founded on. It fosters unquestioning obedience, acceptance of authority, herd mentality, and dependency …;

“Please join us in exploring the problem of state-controlled schooling and the exciting solutions available this very day!”

They have hired local staff, changed their name to the more benign sounding Network for Educational Opportunity and are out raising money from New Hampshire businesses.

We are now in the perverse position of having made a group whose purpose is to shut down public education our sole agent to manage millions of dollars funded by state tax credits.

And what about the schools that would get the money? One will surely be the unaccredited, 340-student Tri-City Christian Academy in Somersworth. Tri-City was the second main lobbyist for the program, is probably the most active school in marketing the vouchers and works with the California group to defend the program against repeal. Here is some of what they say in their philosophy statement, an essay called “The Education Battlefield:”

(more…)

Help poor kids? NH public charters are better than vouchers for religious schools teaching Creationism (letter to the Portsmouth Herald from Gail Mitchell)

Gail Mitchell makes the point that if we want to help poor kids, we’ve got much better ways than vouchers.

Feb. 27 — To the Editor:

The voucher tax credit passed in the last Legislature would take money away from our public schools and send it to private, religious and home schools with no accountability to the public.

I applaud the goal of improving school choice for low-income families. But we already have much better alternatives to vouchers — charter schools.

We have 17 charter schools in New Hampshire and will soon have more. They are public schools and our state Board of Education and Department of Education oversee the quality. They provide a great way to reach children that might not do well in traditional public schools. We even have an online charter school, VLACS, that can supplement regular coursework or provide a full-time curriculum. All of this is free to every New Hampshire child.

Voucher schools, on the other hand, are not accredited by the state. They are not accountable to the taxpayers for the quality of their instruction. Do we want to pay to teach our children that dinosaurs and people walked the earth at the same time? The voucher tax credit program could pay for that! So keep our public schools funded as they are, with the oversight being the taxpayers and the Board of Education. I prefer to have government oversight and state regulations that have kept the high standards of education that New Hampshire children deserve.

Gail Mitchell

Barrington

New tax credit program fights for survival (Eagle Tribune)

Here is a surprisingly long report from last Sunday’s Eagle Tribune on voucher repeal.  Notice particularly the attempt (highlighting added) to bludgeon legislators with the “poor kids” rap, while in the Legislature, voucher supporters are trying to remove the income cap in the program.

Here it is, with my commentary interspersed.

Only weeks after New Hampshire launched its education tax credit program to create private school scholarships for low-income students, it’s in danger.

An initiative led a year ago by Republican lawmakers has come under attack in the Democratic-led House.

It’s also been criticized by educators and others, who say its creates a private school voucher program that takes money intended for public education.

But supporters say the tax credit program offers more educational alternatives for families, especially low-income residents who can’t afford to send their children to private school.

As lawmakers debate the merits of the seven-week-old program in Concord, Kate Baker said she is concerned.

The poor guy got taken in, in spite of this information about the scholarship organization.

(more…)

Sen. Stiles should reject religious school vouchers (Barbara Sweet letter to the Portsmouth Herald)

Another of Sen. Stiles’ constituents weighs in:

An open letter to Sen. Nancy Stiles:

I am writing to urge you to support Bill 370 repealing the voucher bill. I don’t believe that tax money should be supporting religious education. Religious education should occur in privately supported schools, the home and “Sunday schools.” Further, I don’t believe that it would do children any good to move from public to private Christian back to public because of further proof that these unaccountable religious schools do not give a good grounding in academic subjects.

New Hampshire has had a child-friendly reputation of well-educated students with a high percentage of high school graduation. Business wants that. Let’s continue on that path.

Thank you for your consideration.

Barbara Sweet

New Castle

via Sen. Stiles should reject religious school vouchers | SeacoastOnline.com.